Rufe talla

A yau ne alkalan kotun da suka yanke hukunci a mafi girman takaddamar haƙƙin mallaka na shekaru goma da suka gabata suka yanke hukunci. Wasu alkalai tara sun amince baki daya cewa Samsung ya kwafi Apple, kuma ya bai wa giant din Koriya ta Kudu diyya dala biliyan 1,049, wanda ke nufin kasa da kambi biliyan 21.

Alkalan shari'a na maza bakwai da mata biyu sun cimma wani hukunci cikin sauri, wanda ya kawo tsawaita yakin shari'a tsakanin manyan kamfanonin fasahar biyu zuwa karshe da wuri fiye da yadda ake tsammani. Muhawarar ta shafe kwanaki uku kacal. Sai dai kuma, ya kasance mummunan rana ga Samsung, wanda wakilansa suka bar harabar kotun da alkali Lucy Koh ke jagoranta a matsayin wadanda suka yi rashin nasara.

Ba wai kawai Samsung ya keta kaddarorin fasaha na Apple ba, wanda zai aika daidai dala 1 zuwa Cupertino, amma kuma ya gaza zarge-zargen da sauran jam’iyyar ke yi a alkalan kotun. Alkalan kotun ba su gano cewa Apple ya saba wa duk wani hakki na Samsung da aka mika ba, wanda ya bar kamfanin na Koriya ta Kudu hannu wofi.

Don haka Apple zai iya gamsuwa, duk da cewa bai kai adadin dala biliyan 2,75 da ya nema daga Samsung a matsayin diyya ba. Duk da haka, hukuncin ya nuna a fili nasara ga Apple, wanda a yanzu yana da tabbacin kotu cewa Samsung ya kwafi samfuransa da haƙƙin mallaka. Wannan yana ba shi fa'ida don nan gaba, tunda Koreans sun yi nisa da waɗanda Apple ke yaƙi da kowane irin haƙƙin mallaka.

An samu Samsung da laifin keta mafi yawan takardun shaidar da aka gabatar wa alkalan kotun, kuma idan alkali ya ga laifin da gangan ne, za a iya ninka tarar da aka yi masa. Duk da haka, ba a bayar da irin wannan gagarumin adadin a ƙarin diyya. Duk da haka, dala biliyan 1,05, idan ba a canza shi ta hanyar roko ba, zai kasance mafi girman adadin da aka bayar a cikin takaddamar haƙƙin mallaka a tarihi.

Dangane da sakamakon gwajin da ake sa ido a kai, Samsung na cikin hadarin rasa matsayinsa a kasuwannin Amurka, inda ya kasance na daya a kan sayar da wayoyi a cikin 'yan shekarun nan. Wataƙila za a dakatar da wasu samfuransa daga kasuwannin Amurka, wanda za a yanke hukunci a ranar 20 ga Satumba a saurara na gaba daga alkali Lucy Kohová.

Tuni dai masu gabatar da kara suka amince da cewa Samsung ya keta dukkan nau'ikan samfura guda uku na Apple, kamar danna sau biyu don zuƙowa da kuma gungurawa baya. Shi ne aikin na biyu da aka ambata da Samsung ya yi amfani da shi a kan dukkan na'urorin da ake zargi, kuma ko da tare da wasu takardun shaida na kayan aiki, abubuwa ba su da kyau ga kamfanin na Koriya. Kusan kowace na'ura ta keta daya daga cikinsu. Samsung ya ci gaba da samun ci gaba a cikin yanayin ƙirar ƙira, kamar yadda a nan ma, a cewar juri, ya keta duka huɗun. Koreans sun kwafi bayyanar da tsarin gumakan akan allon, da kuma bayyanar gaban iPhone.

[yi action=”tip”] Ana tattauna abubuwan haƙƙin mallaka na ɗaya ɗaya waɗanda Samsung ya keta su dalla-dalla a ƙarshen labarin.[/do]

A wannan lokacin, Samsung yana da doki ɗaya ne kawai ya rage a wasan - iƙirarin da ya yi na cewa haƙƙin mallakar Apple ba su da inganci. Idan da ya yi nasara, da hukunce-hukuncen da suka gabata ba su da wani amfani kuma da kamfanin California ba zai samu ko sisin kwabo ba, amma ko a wannan harka alkalai sun goyi bayan Apple kuma sun yanke shawarar cewa duk takardun mallakar suna da inganci. Samsung kawai ya guje wa tara saboda keta haƙƙin ƙira a kan allunansa guda biyu.

Bugu da kari, Samsung ma ya gaza a kan kararrakin da ya yi, alkalan kotun ba su gano cewa ko daya daga cikin takardunsa guda shida ya kamata Apple ya keta shi ba, don haka Samsung ba zai karbi ko daya daga cikin dala miliyan 422 da ya nema ba. An ce, za a ci gaba da sauraren karar a ranar 20 ga Satumba, kuma ba za mu iya la'akari da wannan takaddama ba tukuna. Samsung ya riga ya bayyana cewa ya yi nisa da fadin kalmar karshe. Duk da haka, za ta iya sa ran hana sayar da kayayyakinta daga bakin Alkali Kohová.

NY Times tuni kawo martani na bangarorin biyu.

Mai magana da yawun Apple Katie Cotton:

“Muna godiya ga alkalan kotun saboda hidimar da suka yi da kuma lokacin da suka saka hannun jari wajen sauraron labarinmu, wanda a karshe muka yi farin cikin sanar da mu. Yawancin shaidun da aka gabatar yayin gwajin sun nuna cewa Samsung ya ci gaba da yin kwafin fiye da yadda muke zato. Dukan tsari tsakanin Apple da Samsung ya kasance game da fiye da kawai haƙƙin mallaka da kuɗi. Ya kasance game da dabi'u. A Apple, muna daraja asali da ƙima kuma muna sadaukar da rayuwarmu don ƙirƙirar samfuran mafi kyau a duniya. Mun ƙirƙira waɗannan samfuran don faranta wa abokan cinikinmu rai, ba don masu fafatawa su kwafi su ba. Muna yaba wa kotu bisa ga yadda Samsung ke gudanar da ayyukansa da gangan da kuma aika sako karara cewa sata ba daidai ba ce.”

Bayanin Samsung:

“Bai kamata a dauki hukuncin na yau a matsayin nasara ga Apple ba, a’a a matsayin hasara ga abokin cinikin Amurka. Zai haifar da ƙarancin zaɓi, ƙarancin ƙima da yuwuwar farashin mafi girma. Abin takaici ne yadda za a iya yin amfani da dokar haƙƙin mallaka don baiwa kamfani ɗaya keɓantacce a kan rectangle mai zagaye ko wata fasaha da Samsung da sauran masu fafatawa ke ƙoƙarin inganta kowace rana. Abokan ciniki suna da 'yancin zaɓar da sanin abin da suke samu lokacin da suka sayi samfurin Samsung. Wannan ba ita ce kalma ta ƙarshe ba a cikin ɗakunan shari'a a duniya, waɗanda tuni wasu daga cikinsu suka yi watsi da yawancin iƙirarin Apple. Samsung zai ci gaba da kerawa da baiwa abokin ciniki zabi. "

Na'urorin da suka saba wa haƙƙin mallaka na Apple

Alamar '381 (dawowa)

Lamba, wanda ban da tasirin "bounce" lokacin da mai amfani ya gungura ƙasa, ya haɗa da ayyukan taɓawa kamar ja da takardu da ayyukan taɓawa da yawa kamar amfani da yatsu biyu don zuƙowa.

Na'urorin da ke keta wannan haƙƙin mallaka: Ƙarfafa, Ci gaba, Droid Charge, Epic 4G, Nunin 4G, Fascinate, Galaxy Ace, Galaxy Indulge, Galaxy Prevail, Galaxy S, Galaxy S 4G, Galaxy S II (AT&T), Galaxy S II (Buɗe), Galaxy Tab, Galaxy Tab 10.1, Gem, Infuse 4G, Mesmerize, Nexus S 4G, Replenish, Vibrant

Alamar '915 (yatsa ɗaya don gungurawa, biyu don tsunkule da zuƙowa)

Alamar taɓawa wanda ke bambanta tsakanin taɓa yatsa ɗaya da biyu.

Na'urorin da ke keta wannan haƙƙin mallaka: Ƙaunar, Ci gaba, Droid Charge, Epic 4G, Nunin 4G, Fascinate, Galaxy Indulge, Galaxy Prevail, Galaxy S, Galaxy S 4G, Galaxy S II (AT&T), Galaxy S II (T-Mobile), Galaxy S II (Buɗe) , Galaxy Tab, Galaxy Tab 10.1, Gem, Infuse 4G, Mesmerize, Nexus S 4G, Canjawa, Vibrant

Alamar '163 (matsa don zuƙowa)

Alamar taɓawa sau biyu wanda ke zuƙowa da cibiyoyi daban-daban na shafin yanar gizon, hoto ko takarda.

Na'urorin da ke keta wannan haƙƙin mallaka: Droid Charge, Epic 4G, Nunin 4G, Fascinate, Galaxy Ace, Galaxy Prevail, Galaxy S, Galaxy S 4G, Galaxy S II (AT&T), Galaxy S II (T-Mobile), Galaxy S II (Buɗe), Galaxy Tab, Galaxy Tab 10.1, Infuse 4G, Mesmerize, Replenish

Patent D'677

Alamar haɗe-haɗe da ke da alaƙa da bayyanar gaban na'urar, a cikin wannan yanayin iPhone.

Na'urorin da ke keta wannan haƙƙin mallaka: Epic 4G, Fascinate, Galaxy S, Galaxy S Showcase, Galaxy S II (AT&T), Galaxy S II (T-Mobile), Galaxy S II (Ba a buɗe), Galaxy S II Skyrocket, Infuse 4G, Mesmerize, Vibrant

Patent D'087

Kama da D'677, wannan lamban kira ya rufe gaba ɗaya shaci da zane na iPhone (taya sasanninta, da dai sauransu).

Na'urorin da ke keta wannan haƙƙin mallaka: Galaxy, Galaxy S 4G, Vibrant

Patent D'305

Alamar lamba da ke da alaƙa da shimfidawa da ƙira na gumakan murabba'i mai zagaye.

Na'urorin da ke keta wannan haƙƙin mallaka: Ƙaunar, Ci gaba, Droid Charge, Epic 4G, Fascinate, Galaxy Indulge, Galaxy S, Galaxy S Showcase, Galaxy S 4G, Gem, Infuse 4G, Mesmerize, Vibrant

Patent D'889

Ƙaƙwalwar haƙƙin mallaka wanda Apple bai yi nasara da shi ba yana da alaƙa da ƙirar masana'antu na iPad. A cewar alkalai, ba Wi-Fi ko nau'ikan 4G LTE na Galaxy Tab 10.1 sun keta shi ba.

Source: TheVerge.com, ArsTechnica.com, CNet.com
.