Ondrej Holzman Kotun Burtaniya a makon jiya yanke shawara, cewa Apple dole ne ya bayyana a fili a kan gidan yanar gizonsa cewa Samsung bai kwafi ƙirarsa da Galaxy Tab ɗin ba. Lauyoyin Apple sun yi amfani da lamarin sosai har ma sun yi wasu tallace-tallace don neman gafara.
Duk da cewa Apple a cikin sanarwar da ya fitar ya ce Samsung bai yi kwafin na'urarsa ba bisa ga hukuncin da kotun ta yanke, amma daga baya ya yi amfani da kalaman alkali a kansa, wanda ya bayyana cewa kayayyakin kamfanin na Koriya ta Kudu ba su da kyau. Tabbas, wannan ya dace da Apple, don haka ya yi amfani da kalmomin guda ɗaya a cikin uzurinsa, inda ya kuma nuna cewa baya ga kotun Burtaniya, alal misali, Jamus ko Amurka ta gane cewa Samsung ya kwafi ƙirar Apple.
Cikakken rubutun uzuri (na asali nan), wanda a zahiri an rubuta shi a cikin font Arial maki 14, ana iya karantawa a ƙasa:
Kotun Burtaniya ta yanke hukunci a kan Samsung vs. Apple (fassara kyauta)
A ranar 9 ga Yuli, 2012, Babban Kotun Ingila da Wales ta yanke hukuncin cewa Samsung's Galaxy Tablets, wato Galaxy Tab 10.1, Tab 8.9 da Tab 7.7, ba sa keta haƙƙin ƙirar ƙirar Apple No. 0000181607-0001. Ana samun kwafin dukan fayil ɗin shari'ar babbar kotun a hanyar haɗin da ke biyowa www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Patents/2012/1882.html.
A yayin yanke shawarar nasa, alkalin ya yi mahimman bayanai da yawa kwatanta ƙirar Apple da na'urorin Samsung:
"Abin mamaki mai sauƙi na ƙirar Apple yana da ban mamaki. A taƙaice, iPad ɗin yana da ƙasa marar kowa tare da gilashin gaba-zuwa-baki tare da bezel mai bakin ciki sosai a cikin launi mai sauƙi. An gama shinge daidai a kusa da gefen kuma ya haɗu da maƙallan sasanninta da gefen gefe. Zane ya yi kama da wani abu da mai amfani ke son ɗauka ya riƙe. Yana da madaidaiciya kuma mai sauƙi, samfuri mai gogewa. Yana da kyau (sanyi) zane.
Gabaɗayan ra'ayin mai amfani na kowane Samsung Galaxy Tablet shine kamar haka: daga gaba, yana cikin rukunin da ya haɗa da ƙirar Apple; amma samfuran Samsung suna da sirara sosai tare da cikakkun bayanai na baya. Ba su da sauƙi iri ɗaya mai ban mamaki wanda ke nuna ƙirar Apple. Ba su da kyau sosai.'
Hukuncin ya shafi dukan Tarayyar Turai kuma Kotun daukaka kara ta amince da shi a ranar 18 ga Oktoba 2012. Ana samun kwafin hukuncin kotun daukaka kara a hanyar da ke biyowa. www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2012/1339.html. Babu wani umarni game da ƙirar ƙira a ko'ina cikin Turai.
Duk da haka, a Jamus, alal misali, wata kotu a can, da ke hulɗa da irin wannan takardar shaidar, ta yanke shawarar cewa Samsung ya yi gasa mara kyau ta hanyar kwafi zane na iPad. Wani alkali a Amurka ya kuma samu Samsung da laifin keta hakin kere-kere da samfurin Apple, wanda aka ci shi tarar sama da dalar Amurka biliyan daya. Don haka yayin da kotun Burtaniya ta samu Samsung da laifin yin kwafin, wasu kotuna sun gano cewa Samsung ya yi kwafin iPad da ya fi shahara a lokacin da ya kera wayoyin Galaxy.
Neman afuwar Apple wata karamar nasara ce kawai ga Samsung a cikin babbar takaddamar haƙƙin mallaka, amma kamfanin na Koriya ta Kudu yana fatan samun ƙarin nasara a nan gaba. Ofishin mallaka ya fara bincikar patent tare da sanyawa US 7469381, wanda ke ɓoye tasirin. billa-baya. Ana amfani da wannan lokacin gungurawa kuma shine tasirin "tsalle" lokacin da kuka isa ƙarshen shafin. Har ma akwai rahotanni a kafafen yada labarai cewa an yi watsi da shi, amma hakan bai kai ga gaci ba. Ofishin Patent a halin yanzu yana binciken ingancin sa ne kawai, kuma dukan lamarin na iya ɗaukar watanni da yawa. Sakamakon zai iya zama amincewa da ingancin haƙƙin mallaka, ko kuma, akasin haka, soke shi. Samsung na fatan zabi na biyu, wanda a karshe ba zai biya Apple irin wannan babban diyya da kotun Amurka ta bayar ba. Koyaya, dole ne mu jira mu ga yadda sake duba ingancin haƙƙin mallaka zai kasance.
Ban fahimci jumlar "...wanda a zahiri aka rubuta a cikin maki 14 Arial font...". Me yasa marubucin ya haskaka wannan? Dole na rasa wani abu. Don Allah wani zai iya bayyana wannan? Godiya :)
Kotu ta umurci Apple a cikin wane nau'in rubutu da girman su dole ne su rubuta uzuri;)
Zan kuskura in ce wannan abin izgili ne na Samsung;) duk mutumin da ke da idanu da kwakwalwa ya san sarai… cewa Samsung kawai yana kwafa ne, don haka uzuri ba shi da amfani ga Samsung;)
apple bata da kyau, tana da kyau kuma kowa ya siya kawai saboda yana da tuffa da aka cije, hannu a zuciya APPLE baya kyau :(
Ban ga wani abu mara kyau ba, ya zuwa yanzu...
Ban san inda a cikin duniyar ku mai gizagizai akwai mafita zuwa rayuwa ta gaske ba. Kuma idan kun samo shi, zaku tabbatar mana duka cewa samfuran Apple cikakke ne, bayan haka, suna kama da mafi kyawun oraz a duniya. Ba karfe ne kawai ba, aikin fasaha ne. Kai! Baka sabawa kanka kwatsam, sunanka Iphone 4S, yana da kyau, yayin da sharhin naka ya bayyana yadda Apple yake da kyau.... Wannan wauta ce ba ku tunani? :)
Mafi kyawun uzuri shekarun da suka gabata, aƙalla a ganina, wannan shine: http://blog.kompost.cz/2007/04/omluva-mgr-radku-hulnovi.html